Jenna Burkhart is tired of being "special" and hearing about what she can't do. Even though she suffered a head injury in a childhood swimming accident, she wants a life of her own just like any Amish woman. But now that she, her mamm, and her mammi have moved to Wells Landing, she's having a hard time fitting in. Until she meets Buddy Miller, a boy just like her, who gives her the confidence to reach for the impossible. But in the face of family disapproval and their own fears, will Jenna and Buddy's courage be enough to give them a forever happiness together?